View Single Post
 January 21, 2020, 22:51 #4 DavidMedley Knight   Join Date: Oct 2019 Posts: 726 I did read the post you linked to before I wrote my little manifesto. I also wrote a couple pages on this very topic (differential vs ratio) a month or two ago, related to a game system I was working on. I didn't want to get too off-topic in my first post, but some items that were of interest: Differential systems are good for easy math Differential systems are inherently exponential When you treat a differential system as linear you can get expectation-breaking results As an illustration, I used very low and high strength characters from D&D (GURPS is even more out of whack in this case). A STR 1 character can carry 15 lbs while a STR 9 character can carry 135 - 9x as much. If they're rolling and adding their STR bonus, the stronger gets +4. A STR 20 giant can carry 300 lbs while a giant can carry 420 lbs - 1.4x as much. If they're rolling and adding their STR bonus, it's the same +4 differential. The two things are out of whack because one is treating STR scores as linear and one, perhaps without really knowing it, is treating STR scores as exponential.