View Single Post
Old August 31, 2009, 20:51   #1
Magnate
Angband Devteam member
 
Join Date: May 2007
Location: London, UK
Posts: 5,057
Magnate is on a distinguished road
Send a message via MSN to Magnate Send a message via Yahoo to Magnate
Using nightly/dev versions

Just wanted to start a discussion about the use of nightly/dev versions and how to go about discussing them. I've seen a few threads recently which make me think that we don't all have the same attitude - I'm just wondering whether I'm in a minority or not.

(Please note that all that follows is definitely IMO only, and I don't speak for Takkaria or any other developer or maintainer.)

IMO the fact that we already have a playable beta (3.1.1.1626 - it's called a beta but it has way fewer bugs than most commercial games) means that we should all play dev versions with VERY low expectations. I know there are major issues with 3.1.0 but in general (i.e. after 3.1.1 becomes "stable") the dev versions are the third tier of the game: a stable version, a "beta" version, and the nightly/trunk versions. IMO you can expect both the first two to be not only playable but relatively bug-free (serious bugs in betas will be fixed). You can't expect the same of the dev versions - that's where major changes get tested, often in stages. It's a perfectly normal part of development if some of those changes get reverted after testing and discussion - so if you happen to play a version in the middle of that progression, it may well suck.

In a former thread (http://angband.oook.cz/forum/showthread.php?t=2095) I suggested that we split discussion of dev versions from discussion of stable (and now beta) versions. I originally suggested a separate subforum, but the Development forum seems as good a place as any.

IMO we should (do more to) encourage new players to play either the stable or beta versions (obviously not 3.1.0 at this moment), and point them here for discussion of their issues. IMO all the discussion of dev versions on here makes it an unhelpful place for new players.

I could be completely wrong - YMMV.

CC
(edit)P.S. I realised that I omitted something which significantly affects my view: it *really* bugs me that this forum software doesn't have "ignore thread" capability - I hate wading through mentally-ignored threads every time they acquire a new post. At the moment I can ignore the entire AAR forum with a custom query, but there's no way to sift through the threads in the V forum. So I wasn't being completely altruistic about new players - there's a selfish motive too. Sorry.

Last edited by Magnate; August 31, 2009 at 21:40.
Magnate is offline   Reply With Quote