Go Back   Angband Forums > Angband > Vanilla

Thread Tools Display Modes
Prev Previous Post   Next Post Next
Old August 26, 2019, 04:39   #1
Join Date: Feb 2019
Location: Midwest
Age: 34
Posts: 397
archolewa is on a distinguished road
Feedback on Angband (4.1.x) from New Player

Hello everyone,

I've been lurking on this forum for a bit now. I think I've been playing Angband for about 10 months or so, and I just had my first victory. I figured I'd write a bragging about it, wrapped up in some feedback so it looks constructive. I haven't tried 4.2 yet (Nick released it while I was in the middle of my run), so my feedback is based on 4.1.x.

First and foremost, I love how this game has raised "discretion is the better part of valor" to an art form. The auto-generated levels, their size, the large number of divination spells available, and all the teleporting all seem to revolve around the idea of inspecting the level, studying the monsters and deciding if it's worth engaging them and how. It's very different from every other game I've played (including most other roguelikes, though the only other one I've more than dabbled in is TOME4), and it's incredibly engaging. Even the controls seem built around it. At first, I bemoaned the game's lack of auto-explore, until I realized that auto-explore goes against what Angband appears to be built around.

I also like how few mechanics there are in the game, and how simple they are. Leveling up is simple, acquiring spells is simple, and the items are simple. It allows me to focus on the meat: the exploration and risk assessment. However, there are enough mechanics, and the mechanics are done well enough that they still combine for very engaging gameplay. I'm very impressed that, despite how old the game is, it hasn't turned into a labryinth of orthogonal features, each one simple and easy to learn incrementally for people who've been playing for decades, but overwhelming to new people.

I think the game has done a very good job of striking a balance between defense and offence. I spent a lot of brain cycles evaluating new equipment, trying to decide if an extra resistance was worth fewer attacks per round, or if a Fire brand was more useful than sound resistance at that point. It made finding equipment very exciting.

I very much appreciated the little in-universe blurbs that each monster and artifact possessed. It gave me just the kind of indirect, exploratory world building that I look for in a roguelike, with lots of open threads for me to build my own backstory. For example, why would Radagast be fighting you in Angband? Has he been corrupted by Morgoth? Have I? Do we both think the other has been? Is he pissed because humans wrecked the world during the Fourth Age and the Valar are so weakened from repairing it that Morgoth managed to get back in? Those little blurbs did a great job of sucking me into the world. I even managed to incorporate the existence of the Monster Memory into my backstory!

Finally, I like how I never feel helpless. I've played some roguelikes where I end up cornered and there's nothing I can do but watch my character die over 20 rounds. I find that incredibly frustrating and disheartening, and I'm glad Angband doesn't have that problem. Even if I do get rendered helpless (say I stupidly removed my Free Action weapon for a pick, and forgot to replace it), the death happens fast enough that at least I don't have to watch it.

There are only two things I don't like, and they're both minor.

I don't like the Speed stat. Moving slower than your enemies is so dangerous, that it almost always ends up being the single most important stat to improve. It makes both artifact discovery and combat less interesting. When looking at two pieces of equipment, the new one had better be pretty incredible to replace your speed buff. Similarly, if an enemy is faster than you, you RUN. If an enemy is slower than you, you can probably take him.

It's not as big a deal in the endgame, because once you get past thirty speed or so, you get diminishing returns, but I didn't get that fast until floor 90+. I don't really have a solution except "remove the Speed stat," but that would be an incredibly disruptive change.

Doing anything in town is incredibly tedious. Mostly because of the existence of all the townsfolk drooling all over you, forcing you to have to spam Spacebar all the time to get through the more prompts whenever you try to run anywhere, or rest. I like having the townsfolk there, contributes to the game's atmosphere, I just wish they didn't pester me so much. I tried disabling the MORE prompt, but then I had too much difficulty keeping track of combat (even with the messages displayed in one of the side windows) for it to be safe. I understand that forced descent is a thing, but I'm not ready for that. I would very much appreciate it if we had a "disable MORE prompt in town only" option that I could turn on once I get past the point where veterans pose a threat.

Sorry about the wall of text, but it seems like most of the people who post on here have been playing for a while, so I thought you guys might appreciate some feedback from a newcomer.

To everyone whose been developing Angband over the last few decades, thank you so much for putting so much of your free time into such a wonderful game!
archolewa is offline   Reply With Quote

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Feedback on 4.0.5 from a 3.0.3 (?) player konijn_ Vanilla 11 November 18, 2016 03:49
Sil: Notes for Angband player TJA Sil 0 January 4, 2016 12:57
Angband Philosophy I: Player choice Nick Vanilla 48 July 8, 2014 15:14
User interface in Angband 4 (feedback requested!) takkaria Vanilla 27 April 7, 2011 19:34
Angband (or variant) Feature Suggestion Poll/Feedback thread PaulBlay Vanilla 77 March 9, 2009 03:40

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 19:55.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, vBulletin Solutions Inc.